How Do the Different Amish Country Popcorn Kernel Varieties Compare?

Updated

Amish Country Popcorn sells several kernel varieties that differ mainly in hull texture, kernel shape, and flavor, and the right pick depends on whether you care most about tender hulls, a soft bite, or a classic crunchy pop. Based on the product descriptions on amishcountrypopcorn.com, here is how the named varieties line up, plus how to choose between them.

The varieties at a glance

Variety What the site says about it Best if you want
Red Flavorful, tender hulls, medium-sized kernels A balance of flavor and a less noticeable hull
White (Hulless) Silky soft, delicate texture, hulless The softest, least chewy bite
Blue Sweet, memorable flavor A sweeter-tasting popcorn
Purple Listed among the "Most POP-ular" kernels To try a colorful, popular variety
Midnight Blue Listed among the "Most POP-ular" kernels A darker-colored kernel with a devoted following
Ladyfinger Hulless Hulless, listed among the "Most POP-ular" kernels Hulless popping in a smaller, finger-shaped kernel
Medium Yellow Classic round kernel, satisfying crunch, sweet buttery flavor, dense pop The traditional movie-theater-style pop

All of these are described as Non-GMO and Kosher, and the individual kernel listings start "From $2.99."

How to choose

The decision comes down to three things the site actually distinguishes between:

  • Hull texture. If chewy hulls bother you, the hulless options (White and Ladyfinger Hulless) are the ones to start with. Red is described as having tender hulls rather than none, so it's a middle ground.
  • Flavor. Blue is called out specifically for a sweet flavor. Medium Yellow is described as sweet and buttery. Red is simply "flavorful."
  • Kernel shape and crunch. Medium Yellow has the classic round kernel and a dense, crunchy pop. Red and the hulless varieties lean softer.

A practical way to decide: pick Medium Yellow if you want the standard, crunchy popcorn most people picture. Pick White or Ladyfinger Hulless if hulls are your main annoyance. Pick Blue if you want sweetness built into the kernel itself. Pick Red if you want flavor with a hull that's easier on the teeth than a standard yellow.

Gift and party options

If you're buying for an occasion rather than for yourself, the site's American Heritage Popcorn Set bundles three 14oz bottles — Red, White, and Blue — with four seasoning shakers (White Cheddar, Nacho Cheese, Dill Pickle, and Extra Buttery Ballpark Style Popcorn Salt) in a gift box. It's listed at a sale price of $19.99 and is positioned as a Fourth of July, cookout, or movie-night gift. That set is the simplest way to try three varieties side by side and compare them yourself.

What applies to every order

  • Satisfaction guarantee: the site states that if you're not 100% satisfied within 90 days of purchase, they'll send a free replacement or issue a full refund.
  • Sourcing: all popcorn is described as grown and sourced from small farms in Indiana.
  • Non-GMO and preservative-free: the site states it never grows genetically modified popcorn and keeps it free of preservatives.

Prices shown here are the sale prices listed on the site at the time of writing and can change; check the individual product pages for current pricing before ordering.