Selling Gold, Silver, Coins, or Watches at Majestic Jewelers

Majestic Jewelers, Inc. buys gold, silver, coins, and other precious metals, as well as high-end watches. The store describes its process as an in-person estimate: you stop by the Winter Park location and staff evaluate your items there. There is no online quote or mail-in program mentioned on the site, so if you want a number, you need to visit in person. The store also states it pays "top dollars" for these items, but no rates, percentages, or fee schedules are published, so the only way to know what you would receive is to get an estimate.

What Majestic Jewelers buys

Based on the store's own service list, the buy-side categories are:

• Gold
• Silver
• Coins
• Other precious metals
• High-end watches

The site frames this as a standing service rather than a one-time event — it's listed alongside custom design, repair, and appraisal as a core part of the business. Majestic has operated in Winter Park since 1986 and describes itself as family owned and operated.

How the estimate process works

The published process is short and in-person:

1. Gather your items. Bring the gold, silver, coins, precious metals, or watches you want evaluated.
2. Visit the store. Majestic's stated method is "stop by today for an estimate" — there is no described appointment requirement, online form, or shipping option.
3. Have staff evaluate the items. The site says its staff of jewelers and sales associates handle customer needs, and that jewelers are on site. It does not publish the specific tools or criteria used for buy-side evaluation.
4. Receive an estimate and decide. Because no pricing is published, treat the in-person estimate as the actual offer point.

What to bring

The site does not provide a document checklist. As a practical matter, for this type of transaction you would typically want:

• The items themselves, separated if you want them evaluated individually
• Any paperwork you already have — receipts, certificates, or appraisals — since the store also offers jewelry appraisal as a separate service
• A photo ID, which is standard for precious-metal transactions, though Majestic does not state this requirement on the page

If you are unsure what to bring for a specific item, call ahead rather than making the trip blind.

Contact and location

Calling 407-644-4824 before visiting is the most reliable way to confirm current hours, whether an appointment helps, and whether a particular item falls within what they buy.

Points to check before you go

• No published buy rates. The site says it pays top dollar but gives no numbers. Compare the in-person estimate against at least one other buyer if the amount matters to you.
• "High-end watches" is undefined. The site does not list which brands or models qualify. If your watch is mid-range rather than high-end, confirm by phone first.
• Coins are listed without qualification. No indication of whether this means bullion, collectible numismatics, or both.
• Website account notice. The site notes a redesigned website is live and that existing customers must reset their password before logging in or placing orders. This affects online accounts, not an in-person selling visit, but it's worth knowing if you also shop with them online.
• Appraisal is a separate service. If you want a written valuation rather than a purchase offer, the store lists jewelry appraisal separately — ask which one fits your goal.

Quick answer

Selling to Majestic Jewelers means bringing your gold, silver, coins, precious metals, or high-end watch to 2234 Aloma Ave in Winter Park and getting an in-person estimate. No prices, rates, or acceptance criteria are published, so call 407-644-4824 with questions about your specific items before making the trip.