What Cookie Flavors and Box Sizes Can I Order from Soul Snacks Cookies?

Updated

Soul Snacks Cookies sells fourteen flavors in boxes of 12, 24, or 36 cookies, with a $12 sampler as the low-commitment entry point. Seven flavors stay in stock year-round, while the other seven rotate through the year one at a time. Everything is baked to order in a South Bronx kitchen and shipped nationwide, and gluten-free and vegan options can go on the same order.

The year-round seven

These are the always-available flavors listed on the site:

  • Classic Chocolate Chip
  • Chocolate Lovers
  • Double Chocolate
  • Lemon Bliss
  • Maple Pecan
  • Oatmeal Raisin

The site describes this group as "always mixing, always in stock" — the seven you can count on regardless of when you order.

Seasonal and rotating flavors

Seven more recipes rotate through the year, one guest flavor at a time. When a rotating flavor sells out, it's gone until it comes back around. The site also runs a vote on which flavor returns next, and says the mailing list at the bottom of the page is the only place the winner's drop date is announced. If you're chasing a specific seasonal flavor, that list is the practical way to catch it.

Box sizes and how ordering works

Every box is baked to order, so you choose a flavor and a size and the kitchen starts from scratch.

Step What you do What happens
1 Pick flavors and a size (12, 24, or 36) Mix as many flavors as you like, or start with the $12 sampler
2 Check out No account needed; gluten-free and vegan options available on the same order
3 Wait for the bake and ship Into the oven after you order, out of the Bronx within two business days

Free shipping applies over $45.

Prices shown on the site

These are the listed prices for the best sellers at the time of writing:

Product Size Price
Down Home Double Chocolate Chip 36 cookies $76.99
Cappuccino Cookie 24 cookies $51.99
Coconut Milk Chocolate Toffee 12 cookies $26.99
Chunked Up Chocolate Walnut 12 cookies $26.99

The site frames the $12 sampler as the answer to a real hesitation: $27 is a lot to spend on a cookie you've never tasted, so the sampler is the smaller way in. If you're ordering for the first time, that's the lowest-risk way to test a flavor before committing to a full box.

Practical notes before you order

  • Baked fresh, never frozen. Production starts after your order, so build in the two-business-day window before shipping.
  • Dietary options exist but aren't itemized per flavor on the page. The site states gluten-free and vegan options are available and can be added to the same order — confirm which specific flavors qualify at checkout.
  • Gifting is a stated use case. The site highlights "great for gifting" and nationwide shipping, so a box of 12 works as a smaller gift while 24 or 36 suits sharing.
  • Free shipping threshold is $45. A single 12-cookie box at $26.99 falls short of it; two boxes or one larger box crosses it.