简体中文
EnglishWhat Is wiki.keyboard.gay (Is This Good?) and What Does It Cover?
Updated
wiki.keyboard.gay hosts "Is this good?", a community-written starter guide to buying parts for mechanical keyboards that take Cherry MX-style switches. It is not a shop, a review database, or an official authority. It is a long reference document that helps you judge whether a specific part will meet your needs, and it deliberately refuses to tell you whether something is simply "good." Use it as a supplement to your own research, and check its revision date, since the guide itself warns that keyboard trends may have moved on since it was written.
What the guide actually argues
The opening makes its position clear: good and bad are not useful categories here. There are only different products that fulfill different needs and niches. The page gives concrete examples of "good enough":
- A prebuilt from a brand like Leopold or Varmilo may be good enough for someone who wants a mechanical keyboard without thinking about it much.
- Gateron Browns may be good enough for someone who only wants a light bump in the press.
- $30 AliExpress keycaps may be good enough for someone who no longer wants thin shinethrough ABS.
- Conversely, thin shinethrough ABS may be exactly what you want if thickness does not matter to you.
The takeaway is that you should arrive with a requirement, not a product name. The guide helps you check whether a candidate purchase meets that requirement.
How the document is organized and how to read it
The page describes itself as a long document with a table of contents, and it explicitly suggests using Ctrl/Cmd-F to jump to the section that applies to you. You are not expected to read it end to end, but the author asks that you read the relevant sections carefully before asking for buying help in community channels.
| Aspect | What to expect |
|---|---|
| Scope | Parts for mechanical keyboards using Cherry MX-style switches |
| Format | Long reference document with a table of contents, meant to be searched |
| Authority | Folk knowledge from the author, co-writers, and trusted second-hand reports |
| Completeness | Not comprehensive across the whole hobby; a starting point |
| Currency | Subject to the revision date; some meta may be out of date |
What it is not
The guide is explicit about its limits. It is not a complete guide to be relied on alone. It does not replace your own searching, YouTube (which it suggests taking with a grain of salt), or the pinned resources in the MechKeys Discord server. It also notes that while it contains some advice about which parts work together, much of the compatibility thinking is still left to you. It is written in a blunt, humorous voice, including a mock refusal to ever be asked whether something is "good" again, so read the tone as intentional rather than hostile.
Who should use it
This is most useful if you are new to the hobby and about to buy your first set of parts, or if you have a specific candidate part and want to understand the tradeoffs before committing. It is less useful if you want a single verdict on a product, a ranked list, or up-to-date pricing. For those, treat the guide as background and verify current details elsewhere.
Practical way to use the page
- Write down your actual requirement first, for example "quiet tactile switch for office use" or "keycaps that do not shine through."
- Open the table of contents and Ctrl/Cmd-F to the relevant section rather than reading linearly.
- Note the revision date and treat any specific product claims as potentially dated.
- Cross-check compatibility and current availability with other sources before buying.
- If you still have questions, the page points to the MechKeys Discord's help and buying-advice channels, where reading the relevant sections first is expected.