What to Know Before Buying Plants from The Sill

Updated

The Sill is an online plant retailer that ships indoor plants, outdoor plants, and trees directly to your door, with free shipping on orders of $99 or more. It fits buyers who want a curated, beginner-friendly selection and are comfortable choosing plants online rather than in a nursery. If you need to inspect a specific plant in person, or you're shopping for something rare and unusual, a local nursery may serve you better.

What The Sill Sells

The catalog splits into a few broad groups:

  • Indoor houseplants — the core of the brand, positioned as beginner-friendly varieties.
  • Outdoor and patio plants — seasonal picks built around patio season.
  • Trees — including citrus and flowering trees, sold as larger, higher-priced items.

The site also sells supplies; a premium potting mix appears in the product listings.

Price Ranges You'll Actually See

Tree pricing on the site gives a concrete sense of the upper end of the catalog. Current listings show:

Plant Listed price Sale price
Meyer Lemon From $169 From $99
Key Lime Bush From $159 From $99
Fukushu Kumquat Tree From $139 From $99
Clementine Mandarin Tree From $139 From $99
Key Lime Tree From $199 From $99
Pink Variegated Eureka Lemon Bush From $129 From $89
Australian Finger Lime Tree From $129 From $99
Genoa Lemon Tree From $139 From $99
Scarlet Colorama Crapemyrtle From $109 From $99
Yoshino Flowering Cherry Tree From $149 From $119
Cherokee Chief Pink Dogwood From $139 From $119
Bubba Jones Desert Willow Tree From $259.95 From $199
Endless Summer Hydrangea From $219 From $79

Two things stand out. First, "From" pricing means the final cost depends on the size or pot you select, so the number you see in a listing isn't necessarily what you'll pay. Second, the sale prices cluster heavily around $99 — which is also the free-shipping threshold. If you're near that line, it's worth checking whether adding a small item pushes you over it.

Shipping and the $99 Threshold

Free shipping applies to orders of $99 or more. Below that, expect a shipping charge, though the site doesn't state the exact rate in the material available here. Practically, this means:

  • A single small houseplant may not qualify for free shipping on its own.
  • Many of the discounted trees land right at or just above $99, so they typically ship free.
  • If you're buying one inexpensive plant, consider whether combining it with soil or another item is worth it to cross the threshold.

Choosing Based on Where the Plant Will Live

The catalog is organized around growing conditions, which makes the decision fairly straightforward:

For a home or apartment interior: Look at the indoor houseplant range. These are the varieties the brand frames as beginner-friendly, and they come with care guides.

For a patio or balcony: The patio plant and citrus tree categories are the relevant ones. Citrus trees like Meyer Lemon and Key Lime are marketed for exactly this use — the site's own framing is "store bought < backyard grown," implying you grow fruit yourself.

For a yard or garden: Flowering trees and shrubs are the fit here. Examples in the current lineup include Yoshino Flowering Cherry, Jane Magnolia, Cherokee Chief Pink Dogwood, Endless Summer Hydrangea, and Peggy Martin Climbing Rose.

Beginner-Friendly Varieties and Care Guides

The Sill's positioning leans on two things: a curated selection aimed at people new to plants, and expert care guides bundled with the plants. If you've killed houseplants before, that combination is the main reason to consider this retailer over a general marketplace — you're paying partly for guidance, not just the plant.

That said, "beginner-friendly" is a label, not a guarantee. A plant that's easy in bright indirect light can still struggle in a dark room, so match the variety to your actual light conditions before buying.

Practical Buying Checklist

Before you check out, confirm:

  1. Light and space — does the plant match the spot you have in mind?
  2. Size at arrival — "From" pricing usually reflects a smaller size; check what you're actually getting.
  3. Shipping total — are you at or above $99, or will shipping be added?
  4. Season — outdoor and patio plants are seasonal picks; timing matters for planting.
  5. Care commitment — trees and larger plants need more long-term attention than a desk plant.

When The Sill Isn't the Right Choice

Skip it if you want to see the exact plant before paying, if you need a species outside the curated range, or if you're buying a single cheap plant where shipping would outweigh the convenience. For those cases, a local nursery or garden center is the more practical route.