What Reviewers Say About Patricia Posner’s Book
Updated
Patricia Posner’s site presents her book as a critically praised work of Holocaust history, with review excerpts that repeatedly describe it as harrowing, well-researched, and compelling. The quoted notices come from literary and general-interest outlets, and they point to two main strengths: historical rigor and clear, gripping prose. If you are deciding whether to read it, the reviews suggest it suits readers who want a serious, documented account rather than a sensationalized one.
The recurring verdict: serious history, vividly told
Across the excerpts, reviewers return to the same qualities:
- Well-researched and accurate — Dallas Morning News calls the research “impeccable,” and Andrew Roberts describes it as “extremely well-researched.”
- Clear, concise prose — MiamiArtZine notes “the prose is clear and concise,” while Roberts says Posner’s “fine prose style grips from page one.”
- Harrowing but not sensational — Jewish Renaissance Magazine says “Posner avoids sensationalism and gives us a harrowing and important read.”
- Gripping and memorable — San Francisco Book Review calls it “a very hair-raising, eye-opening, breath-taking story,” and MiamiArtZine calls it “a gripping read.”
What each outlet emphasizes
| Source | Main point in the excerpt |
|---|---|
| Kirkus Review (Nov. 1, 2016) | “A gruesome story eloquently told” |
| Jewish Renaissance Magazine (Jan. 2017) | Avoids sensationalism; harrowing and important |
| San Francisco Book Review | Vivid, immersive storytelling; strong emotional impact |
| Dallas Morning News | Doubles as the story of I.G. Farben and profiles Nazi hunter Fritz Bauer |
| MiamiArtZine (Dec. 2016) | Impeccable research, clear prose, highly recommended |
| Andrew Roberts, author of The Storm of War | Beautifully written, extremely well-researched, gripping from page one |
| Damien Lewis, author of The Nazi Hunters | “Shocking. Revelatory. Compelling… A milestone in WWII and Holocaust history.” |
What the reviews suggest about the book’s scope
The Dallas Morning News excerpt adds a detail the other notices only hint at: the book is not solely a portrait of one figure. It also tells the story of Nazi Germany’s largest industrial conglomerate, I.G. Farben, and offers an in-depth profile of Nazi hunter Fritz Bauer, described as “relentless in hunting down Capesius and bringing him to justice.” Readers interested in corporate complicity, postwar justice, and the mechanics of Nazi hunting will find those threads highlighted by reviewers.
How to use these reviews
The excerpts are short promotional quotations, not full reviews, so treat them as signals of tone and emphasis rather than complete assessments. They are most useful for judging fit:
- If you want documented history with a strong narrative, the repeated praise for research and prose supports that expectation.
- If you prefer restrained treatment of difficult material, the Jewish Renaissance note about avoiding sensationalism is the most relevant.
- If you want context beyond a single biography, the Dallas Morning News description of the I.G. Farben and Fritz Bauer material is the clearest indicator.
For the fullest picture, read the complete reviews at the original outlets; the site itself provides only these selected quotations.