Website review
This review may include AI-generated content and is not individually verified. Domain, certificate and other facts come from the observed data on this page.
What is Basic Income New Zealand (BINZ)?
Basic Income New Zealand (BINZ) is an advocacy organisation that promotes the universal, unconditional basic income concept in Aotearoa New Zealand. Its site presents basic income as an income paid to all citizens as individuals, without distinctions, means-testing or work requirements.
H3 What the organisation argues
- Basic income is framed as a poverty fix that supports a fairer, happier and healthier society.
- Automation and artificial intelligence are described as making jobs insecure; the site cites a 2013 Oxford University study arguing 47 percent of existing jobs may be lost by 2033.
- It argues a basic income need not cost more than the current welfare system, calling it a different mechanism for distributing income.
- Several proposals for introducing basic income in New Zealand are shown on the website, most involving tax changes for people with earned income.
- BINZ has campaigned for a universal basic income for all New Zealand children, citing child poverty.
H3 Who it is for The site suits New Zealanders curious about basic income, students and researchers looking for local proposals, and advocates wanting arguments and resources. It is not a government agency or welfare provider, and the site does not present itself as administering payments.
H3 A practical next step If you are weighing up the idea rather than just reading about it, decide which question matters most to you: how it would be funded, how it would affect your household, or how it compares with existing welfare. The site's resources page is the obvious starting point for evidence, and for international advocacy perspectives you can compare Scott Santens, whose work the site highlights.
How would a basic income be funded in New Zealand without increasing costs compared to the current welfare system?
The site's central claim is that a basic income does not have to cost more than the existing welfare system because it is "simply a different mechanism for distributing income." In other words, the money already spent on benefits, supplements and administration would be redirected into unconditional payments, with the design of the tax and transfer system doing the work of raising and returning it.
According to the page, most of the proposals it collects involve tax changes for people with earned income. That is the standard shape of the argument: a basic income paid to everyone, funded by adjusting the tax scale so that higher earners pay back more of what they receive. The site does not put a figure on the rate or the tax changes here; it points readers to its resources page and to the various New Zealand proposals it hosts for the specifics.
A few practical points follow from how the site frames it:
- Redistribution, not new money. The comparison is with the total cost of the current welfare system, including the costs of means-testing and administration. Whether a basic income genuinely costs no more depends on the rate chosen and the tax structure that funds it.
- Winners and losers. Because everyone receives the payment but funding comes mainly from earned income, the effect on any household depends on its earnings and size. That is the trade-off a proposal has to spell out.
- Simplicity versus targeting. Unconditional payments remove means-testing and work requirements, which the site presents as an advantage, but they also pay people who do not need the money. The offsetting tax changes are what make the arithmetic work.
The site also notes that a basic income for children is presented as an answer to child poverty, citing Graeme Coleman of Horizon Research, and that BINZ has campaigned for a universal basic income for all New Zealand children.
If you want to test the "no extra cost" claim for yourself, take any proposal on the site and check two numbers: the payment rate and the tax changes that fund it. If the two do not balance across the whole population, the claim does not hold. For the wider international debate, Basic Income Earth Network and Scott Santens are useful starting points; the site itself links to Santens' work.
What evidence exists that basic income reduces child poverty in New Zealand?
The site argues that a basic income for children is a direct answer to child poverty in New Zealand, citing Horizon Research principal Graeme Coleman, and it notes that BINZ has campaigned for a universal basic income for all New Zealand children, framing it as a way for the country to lead internationally. It also reports that Treasury recommended investigating basic income to the Welfare Working Group and references a Newshub item from August 2018. On the international evidence, the page says pilot studies show basic income reduces paid work hours mainly among children and mothers, which it treats as a benefit rather than a drawback.
That is advocacy argument and second-hand reporting, not a body of measured child-poverty outcomes in New Zealand. No New Zealand basic income pilot with published poverty-reduction results is described here.
H3 Practical reading of the claim
- The strongest concrete point is the design argument: paying unconditionally to each child, as an individual, avoids means-testing and work requirements, so it reaches households that conditional welfare can miss.
- The cited pilot evidence concerns labour supply, not child poverty rates. Reduced paid hours by mothers can raise or lower household income depending on the payment size and how it is taxed back from earners, so it does not by itself prove a poverty reduction.
- Cost claims are framed relatively: the site says a basic income need not cost more than the current welfare system because it is a different distribution mechanism, with most proposals involving tax changes for people with earned income. Whether children come out ahead depends entirely on those tax and payment settings.
H3 Who this is useful for A policy researcher or student can use the page to find the New Zealand advocacy position and named proposals, then check the underlying sources on its resources page. A journalist or campaigner can treat the Coleman and Newshub references as leads to verify. A general reader wondering whether basic income "works" for child poverty should look for actual outcome data — poverty rates, hardship measures, household incomes — rather than labour-supply findings alone.
H3 Next step Follow the site's resources page to the original study and pilot reports, then compare three things: the payment per child, the tax treatment of that payment and of parents' earnings, and the measured poverty or hardship outcome. For independent context on basic income debates and pilots, see Basic Income Earth Network and OECD.
How does automation and AI job loss affect the need for a basic income?
Automation and AI job loss strengthen the case for a basic income mainly by widening the gap between paid work and the income people need to live. Basic Income New Zealand frames this as a demand problem as much as an employment problem: if fewer people earn wages, fewer people can buy what businesses produce. A basic income, in that argument, keeps customers in the economy while letting businesses adopt new technology.
The site also treats insecurity, not just outright job loss, as the trigger. It cites a 2013 Oxford University study suggesting 47 percent of existing jobs could be lost by 2033, and says advances in automation and AI are making jobs insecure now. The claim that a basic income need not cost more than the current welfare system is presented as a different distribution mechanism, not necessarily a larger one.
What the site says about work incentives
One of the more useful points is that a basic income may not cause the mass withdrawal from paid work that critics fear. The site points to pilot evidence suggesting reductions in paid work hours are concentrated among children and mothers. Its interpretation is that financial security gives people more choice about balancing work, family and community commitments, including starting businesses, volunteering, retraining or staying home with children.
How to weigh the automation argument
| Consideration | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Speed of displacement | If job loss is gradual, retraining and targeted support may suffice; if it is rapid or concentrated, unconditional income is easier to administer |
| Who is affected | Automation tends to hit specific regions, industries and skill levels, so place-based hardship can be severe even when national employment looks fine |
| Funding mechanism | The site notes most New Zealand proposals involve tax changes for people with earned income, so the real question is who pays and who gains |
| Existing welfare design | Means-testing and work requirements can leave gaps during retraining or insecure work; unconditional payments avoid those gaps but also go to people who do not need them |
A practical next step is to separate two claims: that automation will destroy jobs, and that a basic income is the best response. The first is an empirical forecast; the second is a design choice. If you are evaluating this for New Zealand specifically, compare the proposals on the site against the current welfare system on coverage, conditionality and effective marginal tax rates for people moving into work.
For broader context, the site references advocate Scott Santens, whose work is at Scott Santens. You can also compare how other countries debate the same issue through Basic Income Earth Network.
What pilot studies show about basic income's effect on paid work hours?
Pilot studies generally find that a basic income reduces paid work hours only modestly, and the reductions cluster among specific groups rather than across the whole population. On this site, Basic Income New Zealand summarises that evidence by saying the effect appears mainly among children and mothers, which it reads as a sign that a basic income lets families spend more time on caregiving rather than signalling that people stop working.
That framing is the site's interpretation, not a neutral survey of the literature. A more cautious reading is that the same result can support two different conclusions: either a basic income frees people to do unpaid work they value, or it draws some people out of paid employment. Which one matters depends on what you are trying to measure.
What to check before trusting any pilot result
- Who reduced hours. If the drop is concentrated among students, new mothers or carers, the labour-market story is very different from a broad decline across prime-age workers.
- Whether the payment was truly unconditional. Pilots that taper the payment away as earnings rise are testing a negative income tax, not a basic income, and their work incentives differ.
- Duration. Short pilots can capture a pause between jobs; multi-year pilots are better at showing whether people return to paid work.
- What counts as work. Unpaid care, study and volunteering often sit outside the headline employment figures, so a fall in paid hours is not the same as a fall in productive activity.
A concrete way to use this
Suppose you are preparing a submission on a New Zealand basic income proposal. Rather than citing a single headline number, separate the claim into two parts: the observed effect on paid hours, and the value of the unpaid activity that replaces those hours. The site's own argument leans on the second part — that financial security lets people choose how to balance work, family and community commitments. That is a reasonable position, but it needs the unpaid-work side to be evidenced, not assumed.
For the wider case the site makes, including automation and child poverty, its resources page is the natural next stop: Basic Income New Zealand. For an international advocate whose work the site cites directly, see Scott Santens.
How can I get involved with or support the Basic Income New Zealand campaign?
Basic Income New Zealand (BINZ) is an advocacy group, not a benefits agency, so "getting involved" means adding your voice, time or money to the campaign rather than applying for a payment. The site presents itself as promoting the unconditional basic income concept in Aotearoa and highlights campaigns such as a Basic Income for all New Zealand children.
Practical ways to support a campaign like this
- Join or start a local discussion group. BINZ frames basic income as a public conversation about poverty, automation and fairness, so hosting a meetup, workplace lunch or community hui is a direct contribution.
- Write to MPs and select committees. The site notes that Treasury recommended investigating basic income for the Welfare Working Group, which shows the idea has had a formal policy audience. A short submission or letter referencing that history is concrete and useful.
- Share the arguments, not just the slogan. The site's core case is that a basic income is unconditional, paid to individuals, and could be funded by reshaping the existing welfare system rather than simply adding to it. Explaining that distinction helps move the debate past "free money" objections.
- Volunteer skills. Advocacy groups typically need design, research, translation into te reo Māori, social media and event help. Offer what you already do well.
- Donate or subscribe if the site offers it. The page carries subscription language, so check the site itself for current membership or donation options rather than assuming a set amount.
Where to look next
The site points readers to its resources page for research, including the often-cited Oxford study suggesting a large share of jobs could be displaced by automation. Start there if you want evidence to bring to a conversation, then use the site's own contact or campaign pages to ask how you can help.
For broader context on the international movement, Basic Income Earth Network and Scott Santens are named or referenced in the material above.
User reviews (0)